Our Mission

Since Gary Reiterman purchased Reiterman Feed & Supply on November 1st, 1999, our mission has been to serve our customers with premium feed, supplements, and supplies for livestock, horses, and pets. They also carry a great selection of lawn and garden and softener salt. Managed today by John Reiterman and Nicol Reiterman, they offer trusted brands and expert service to Madison and surrounding counties. Whether you need a custom mix, bulk feed delivery, softener salt loaded in your car or delivered to your house or pet nutrition advice, we’re here to support your needs with a hometown touch.

Our Vision

Reiterman Feed & Supply aims to be the go-to resource for Mt. Sterling’s farming and animal care community, growing beyond our 1999 roots into a hub for innovative, sustainable solutions. With over 25 years of family-owned experience, we’re committed to enhancing Madison County with quality products—from equine nutrition to livestock feed—and a welcoming store that strengthens Ohio’s agricultural heartland for generations ahead.

The Reiterman Feed & Supply Monthly Newsletter

Company Founders

Gary Reiterman, Founder and Patriarch of Reiterman Feed & Farm

Gary Reiterman is the heart of the Reiterman family and the foundation of Reiterman Feed, a trusted feed store and family farm in Mt. Sterling, Ohio. A proud graduate of The Ohio State University, Gary remains an avid Buckeyes football fan, attending games whenever possible. As a dedicated farmer, he continues to play an active role in the family farm and feed store operations, even in retirement. Gary is a father to two sons, Mike and John, and a proud grandfather to three grandchildren and three great-grandchildren. His lifelong commitment to agriculture and the Ohio farming community inspires the Reiterman Feed legacy.

John Reiterman, Co-Manager of Reiterman Feed

John Reiterman co-manages Reiterman Feed, bringing expertise and passion to the Mt. Sterling feed store and family farm. Raised in the Mt. Sterling, Ohio area, John graduated from Miami Trace High School and earned a Bachelor of Science in Agriculture from Wilmington College. With years of experience raising show pigs, John is a respected figure in the Ohio livestock and agriculture community. He resides in Columbus, Ohio, with his fiancée, Laura, and remains dedicated to providing high-quality animal feed and farming supplies to local farmers and livestock enthusiasts.

Nicol Reiterman, Co-Manager of Reiterman Feed

Nicol Reiterman co-manages Reiterman Feed alongside her brother-in-law, John, and is a driving force behind the Mt. Sterling feed store’s success. Married to Mike Reiterman, Nicol is a proud mother of three and grandmother to three. Beyond the feed store, she operates the mobile show trailer at jackpot livestock shows and county fairs across Ohio for approximately 20 weekends each year, connecting with the Ohio livestock community. As a State Trustee for the Ohio Farm Bureau, Nicol represents Fayette, Clinton, Warren, and Greene Counties, advocating for Ohio farmers and promoting sustainable agriculture.

A quote from a company employee

Employee Name